Tracks: Disc: 1
1. Shine On [Performed by the Cast of Tarzan]
2. St. Nick Swing [Performed by the Cast of The Producers]
3. Bring a Torch/Joy to the World/Go Tell It [Performed by the cast of The Color Purple]
4. Birthday of a King [Performed by the Cast of Les Miserables]
5. This Little Light of Mine [Performed by the Cast of Mary Poppins]
6. O Come, O Come Emmanuel [Performed by the Cast of Mamma Mia]
7. Gospel Hallelujah [Performed by the Cast of Hairspray]
8. Key to Christmas [Performed by the Cast of Beauty & The Beast]
9. Angels We Have Heard on High (On a Theme of Jonathan Larson) [Performed by the Cast of Rent]
10. Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas [Performed by the cast of The Phantom of the Opera]
11. Lullay, Thou Little Tiny Child [Performed by the Cast of Chicago]
12. First Noel [Performed by the Cast of Wicked]
13. O Come All Ye Faithful [Performed by the Cast of A Chorus Line]
14. O Holy Night [Performed by the Cast of Jersey Boys]
15. Go Tell It on the Mountain [Performed by the Cast of The Lion King]
16. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen [Performed by the Cast of Sweeney Todd]
17. Auld Lang Syne [Performed by the Cast of Company]
Disc: 2
1. Holi-Daze [Performed by the Cast of Avenue Q]
2. December's Other, Less Famous Holiday [Performed by the cast of The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee]
3. Joseph's Dream [Performed by the Cast of Altar Boyz]
4. Something Must Be Wrong with My Mistletoe [Performed by the cast of Di - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels]
5. Hanukah Song [Performed by the Cast of The Wedding Singer]
6. Like a Snowman [Performed by the Cast of Kiki & Herb]
7. Rockin' Christmas Angel [Performed by the Cast of The Drowsy Chaperone]
8. [holiday story] [Performed by the cast of (title of show)]
9. O Little Town of Bethlehem [Performed by the cast of Monty Python's Spamalot]
