| Type | Cover | Title ![]() | Date | Source | |
| Audio | American in Paris, An / In the Good Old Summertime (In the Good Old Summertime) | 1949 | Film Soundtrack | ||
| Audio | The Broadway Bombshell Sings Showstoppers | N/A | Nancy Walker | ||
| Audio | Comden and Green Perform Their Own Songs (It's Always Fair Weather) | 1955 | Betty Comden and Adolph Green | ||
| Audio | The Complete Gilbert & Sullivan (Iolanthe) | 1960 | The D'Oyly Carte Opera Company | ||
| Audio | Connecticut Yankee, A / Inside U.S.A. (Inside U.S.A.) | 1948 | Original Cast members | ||
| Audio | The Essential Liza Minnelli | 1965 | Liza Minnelli | ||
| Audio | I Aliki Tragoudaei Ta Megala Miouzikal | 1996 | Aliki Vougiouklaki | ||
| Audio | I Am a Singer | 2007 | Kumiko Mori | ||
| Audio | I Am Anne Frank (Yours, Anne) | 1996 | Studio Cast | ||
| Audio | I Am What I Am | 1986 | Pia Zadora | ||
| Audio | I Am What I Am | 1995 | Danny LaRue | ||
| Noncommercial Audio | I Anastasia (Anya) | 1965 | Publisher's Demo | ||
| Audio | I and Albert | 1972 | Original London Cast | ||
| Audio | I Believe My Heart (The Woman In White) | 2004 | Duncan James & Keedie | ||
| Audio | I Believe My Heart: Broadway Duets with All My Leading Men | 2006 | Laurie Gayle Stephenson | ||
| Audio | I Believe My Own Eyes (Tommy) | 1993 | Pete Townsend | ||
| Audio | I Can Cook, Too | N/A | Nancy Walker | ||
| Noncommercial Audio | I Can Get It For You Wholesale | 1962 | Demo Recording | ||
| Audio | I Can Get It For You Wholesale | 1962 | Original Broadway Cast | ||
| Audio | I Can Get It For You Wholesale | N/A | Sy Oliver and his Orchestra | ||
| Audio | I Can't Keep Running In Place | 1981 | Original Off-Broadway Cast | ||
| Audio | I Choose Love | 2003 | Heather MacRae | ||
| Audio | I Could Fall in Love: Greatest Hits, Vol. 4 | 2006 | Bill Solly | ||
| Audio | I Could Go On Singing | 1962 | Judy Garland | ||
| Audio | I Do! I Do! | 1966 | Original Broadway Cast | ||
| Audio | I Do! I Do! | 1968 | Original London Cast | ||
| Audio | I Do! I Do! | 1969 | Japanese Cast | ||
| Video | I Do! I Do! | 1982 | Television Cast | ||
| Audio | I Do! I Do! | 1996 | Off-Broadway Cast | ||
| Audio | I Don't Know How To Love Him | 1999 | Various | ||
| Audio | I Dreamed A Dream | 2000 | Michael Ball | ||
| Audio | I Feel A Song Coming On | 1974 | Jill Perryman | ||
| Audio | I Get a Kick Out of ... Cole Porter | N/A | The Allen Toussaint Orchestra | ||
| Audio | I Get a Kick Out of You | 1995 | Ethel Merman | ||
| Audio | I Get A Kick Out Of You: Cole Porter Songbook, Vol. 2 | 1991 | Various Artists | ||
| Audio | I Got Rhythm: Fiedler Conducts Gershwin | 1979 | The Boston Pops | ||
| Audio | I Got Rhythm: The Smithsonian George Gershwin Collection | 1995 | George Gershwin | ||
| Audio | I Had a Ball | 1964 | Original Broadway Cast | ||
| Audio | I Had a Ball | N/A | Lester Lanin | ||
| Audio | I Hate Men | 1959 | Nancy Walker | ||
| Audio | I Have Dreamed | 1993 | David Silverman | ||
| Noncommercial Audio | I Just Wanna Dance (The Remixes) (Jerry Springer, the Opera) | 2004 | Alison Jiear | ||
| Audio | I Just Want To Sing | 1985 | Joe Williams | ||
| Audio | I Know You By Heart | 1999 | Lee Lessack | ||
| Audio | I Love Melvin | 1953 | Film Soundtrack | ||
| Audio | I Love My Wife | 1977 | Original Broadway Cast | ||
| Noncommercial Audio | I Love My Wife | 1977 | Demo Recording | ||
| Audio | I Love My Wife | 1978 | South African Cast | ||
| Audio | I Love My Wife | 1982 | Australian Cast | ||
| Audio | I Love New York | 1998 | Original Cast |