

| The Fantasticks | 1960 | Off-Broadway Cast | ||
| The Fantasticks | 1973 | Japanese Cast | ||
| The Fantasticks | 1993 | Japan Tour Cast | ||
| The Fantasticks | 1997 | Studio Cast (Karaoke) | ||
| The Fantasticks | 2000 | Kings College Cast, Wimbledon | ||
| The Fantasticks | 2006 | Off-Broadway Revival Cast | ||
| 1967 | 1967 | Betty Buckley | ||
| The Champion Season: Live at the Cafe Carlyle | 1999 | Barbara Cook | ||
| Earthly Paradise | 2007 | Susan Watson |
Note: this song may also appear on other recordings whose tracks have not yet been indexed.