

| The Last Five Years | 2002 | Original Off-Broadway Cast |
Note: this song may also appear on other recordings whose tracks have not yet been indexed.
| Climbing Uphill (2) | ||
| Goodbye Until Tomorrow (3) | ||
| I Can Do Better Than That (3) | ||
| I Could Never Rescue You (2) | ||
| If I Didn't Believe in You (3) | ||
| If I Didn't Believe In You (Reprise) | ||
| Irish Girls | cut song | |
| A Miracle Would Happen (2) | ||
| Moving Too Fast (2) | ||
| The Next Ten Minutes (3) | ||
| Nobody Needs to Know (2) | ||
| A Part of That (2) | ||
| The Schmuel Song (2) | ||
| See I'm Smiling (2) | ||
| Still Hurting (3) | ||
| A Summer in Ohio (2) | ||
| When You Come Home to Me (2) |