

| Carrie | 1986 | Workshop | |
| Carrie | 1988 | Original Broadway Cast |
Note: this song may also appear on other recordings whose tracks have not yet been indexed.
| Ain't It a Bitch? | Cut from workshop, replaced by "In" | |
| Alma Mater | ||
| Bows | ||
| Carrie | ||
| Carrie (Finale) (No recordings) | ||
| Carrie (Reprise 2) | ||
| Carrie (Reprise) | ||
| The Destruction | ||
| Do Me a Favor (2) | ||
| Don't Waste the Moon (2) | ||
| Dream On (2) | ||
| An Eagle's Just Another Bird | Cut from workshop | |
| Evening Prayers (2) | ||
| Exit Music | ||
| Heaven | ||
| Heaven (Reprise) | ||
| I Can Hear My Heart | Cut from workshop, replaced by "Carrie" | |
| I Never Dreamed | ||
| I Remember How Those Boys Could Dance (2) | ||
| I'm Not Alone | ||
| In | ||
| It Hurts to Be Strong | ||
| It Only Has to Happen Once | Cut from workshop, replaced with "Unsuspecting Hearts" | |
| The Lord's Prayer | Cut from workshop | |
| Open Your Heart (2) | ||
| Out For Blood | ||
| Unsuspecting Hearts | ||
| Unsuspecting Hearts (Reprise) | ||
| When There's No One (2) | ||
| Wotta Night |