

| Peter Pan | 1954 | Original Broadway Cast | ||
| Peter Pan | 1997 | London Studio Cast |
Note: this song may also appear on other recordings whose tracks have not yet been indexed.
| Bows & End Titles | ||
| Captain Hook's Waltz (4) | Music: Jule Styne (201); Lyrics: Adolph Green (120), Betty Comden (116) | |
| Distant Melody (5) | Music: Jule Styne (201); Lyrics: Adolph Green (120), Betty Comden (116) | |
| Farewell | ||
| Finale (3) | ||
| Hook's Tango (3) | ||
| Hook's Tarantella (3) | ||
| I Gotta Crow (Reprise) | ||
| I Won't Grow up (6) | ||
| I'm Flying (7) | ||
| I've Gotta Crow (3) | ||
| Indians (2) | ||
| Never, Never Land (8) | Music: Jule Styne (201); Lyrics: Adolph Green (120), Betty Comden (116) | |
| Oh, My Mysterious Lady (3) | Music: Jule Styne (201); Lyrics: Adolph Green (120), Betty Comden (116) | |
| Overture (3) | ||
| Pirate Song (3) | ||
| Tender Shepherd (4) | ||
| Tiger Lily's Dance | ||
| Ugg-a-wugg (3) | Music: Jule Styne (201); Lyrics: Adolph Green (120), Betty Comden (116) | |
| Wendy (3) | Music: Jule Styne (201); Lyrics: Adolph Green (120), Betty Comden (116) | |
| When I Went Home | Cut prior to opening |