 | West Side Story | 1957 | Original Broadway Cast | |
 | West Side Story | 1958 | Manny Albam and His Jazz Greats | |
 | West Side Story |  | 1961 | Film Soundtrack |
 | West Side Story | 1962 | Oscar Peterson Trio | |
 | West Side Story | 1962 | London Studio Cast | |
 | West Side Story | 1965 | Studio Cast | |
 | West Side Story | 1966 | London Studio Cast | |
 | West Side Story | 1966 | Studio Cast | |
 | West Side Story | 1977 | Japanese Cast | |
 | West Side Story | | 1985 | Studio Cast |
 | West Side Story | 1993 | London Studio Cast | |
 | West Side Story | 1993 | Leicester Cast | |
 | West Side Story | 1996 | Dutch Cast | |
 | West Side Story | 1996 | Studio Cast | |
 | West Side Story | | 2001 | Nashville Symphony Orchestra & Cast |
 | Broadway's Fair Julie Andrews | 1961 | Julie Andrews with Henri René and His Orchestra | |
 | Alfred Drake and Roberta Peters Sing the Popular Music of Leonard Bernstein | 1963 | Alfred Drake and Roberta Peters | |
 | A Little Bit Of Broadway | | 1977 | Julie Andrews |
 | I Wish It So | | 1994 | Dawn Upshaw |
 | Dawn at Dusk | 1996 | Dawn Upshaw | |
 | Broadway Classic | | 2000 | Lisa Vroman |
 | West End Girls | 2001 | Various | |
 | Songs of Stephen Sondheim, Vol. 2 | 2005 | Karaoke | |
 | Showtime | 2006 | Sarah Ryan |
Note: this song may also appear on other recordings whose tracks have not yet been indexed.
| America (16) | ||
| Balcony Scene (2) | ||
| Ballet Sequence (2) | ||
| Blues | ||
| A Boy Like That (14) | ||
| Cool (15) | ||
| Dance At The Gym (3) | ||
| Finale (4) | ||
| Gee, Officer Krupke! (13) | ||
| I Have a Love (15) | ||
| Jet Song (12) | ||
| Mambo | ||
| Maria (27) | ||
| One Hand, One Heart (18) | ||
| Overture | ||
| Prologue (6) | ||
| Promenade | ||
| Quintet (Tonight) (7) | ||
| The Rumble (4) | ||
| Scherzo | ||
| Something's Coming (30) | ||
| Somewhere (36) | ||
| Taunting Scene (3) | ||
| Tonight (31) |